April 7, 2007: History of the Baker's Dozen

According to Wikipedia:
The oldest known source and most probable origin for the expression "baker's dozen" dates to the 13th century in one of the earliest English statutes, instituted during the reign of Henry III (r. 1216-1272), called the Assize of Bread and Ale. Bakers who were found to have shortchanged customers could be liable to severe punishment. To guard against the crude punishment of losing a hand to an axe, a baker would give 13 for the price of 12, to be certain of not being known as a cheat. Specifically, the practice of baking 13 items for an intended dozen was to prevent "short measure", on the basis that one of the 13 could be lost, eaten, burnt or ruined in some way, leaving the baker with the original dozen. The practice could be seen in the guild codes of the Worshipful Company of Bakers in London.

Modern uses
While modern bakers no longer fear medieval law, they have found other reasons for a baker's dozen, as seen in the tidy way 13 disks (loaves, cookies, biscuits, etc.) can pack a rectangle (baking tray) of appropriate proportions. Modern standard sized packing trays have a 3:2 aspect ratio, and the most efficient two-dimensional array is hexagonal close packing, which has sixfold symmetry, such that each baked item is equidistant from its six nearest neighbors. The corners of a cookie sheet heat up and cool off faster than the edges and interior, so any item placed near a corner will not bake at the same rate as the other items. A 4+5+4 arrangement provides the dense hexagonal packing while avoiding corners, and would have been discovered empirically by bakers with the goal of baking the maximum number per batch with optimal uniformity. Continued use also stems from tradition, and some customers see it as a sign of appreciation from the baker for continued patronage.

Albuquerque Tom
I don't mean to be a know-it-all but that Wikipedia report is all wrong.

The term Baker's dozen comes from Dusty Baker's on deck circle experience on April 8, 1974 while Hank Aaron hit home run # 715 to surpass the flabby and unathletic Babe (whose batting average in today's game would be .214 with a career home run total just 4 above Steve Jeltz). It turns out that Dusty had a bad case of diarrhea that day (he thinks it's from eating off of Phil Neikro's plate the night before) and had already gone to the bathroom 12 times. With all of the hoopla and celebration going on, Dusty had to go to restroom again and couldn't wait any longer. He ran back in to the clubhouse and opened up the floodgates. As he ran back to the batter's box just in time Jack Impy, unofficial Braves statistician, called out "Dusty, what is that? 13 times on the crapper today?"

Baker shouted out, "12", and Impy wrote down "Baker's Dozen" on the BM line, knowing that Dusty's 12 really equaled 11. This record would have become much more prestigious had it not been overshadowed by Hank Aaron's inevitable conquering of Babe Ruth's right-time-right-place so called achievement. It was the first time a Braves player had gone to the bathroom over 10 times and earned dusty the nickname '13 Timer' from his closest friends.

Now, oddly enough, one area where the Babe excelled: Babe Ruth actually used the crapper 14 times EVERY DAY OF HIS LIFE.

How the term Baker's dozen got transferred to donuts is a story that one of you will have to share.

P.S. Regarding the Wikipedia quote: "While modern bakers no longer fear medieval law..."

This is also not true.

Ask any baker anywhere.

They are scared as hell.

White Russian
The story of how the Baker's Dozen got associated with donuts starts with Phil Niekro. For, you see, Phil (who's plate the night before was suspected of giving Dusty the now infamous diarrhea) was a closet donut fiend. On game days, Niekro would hide in his closet and eat an entire bag of donut holes. Forty four seconds after the last donut hole, Phil would force himself to vomit inside a jar. (He would wait exactly 44 seconds, by the way, in honor of the great Hank Aaron, who wore the number 44.) The jar stayed in Niekro's closet until he had a chance to dispose of the evidence of his behavior without being caught. Niekro, in fact, was the first known practitioner of the "splurge and purge" move so often employed by teen age girls who are insecure in their body image. Niekro had no body image issues - his entire routine was completely superstitious. How that superstition started is yet another story that is better told by someone else.

Getting back to Dusty's connection, the night before Phil had been a little distracted. He was not feeling as comfortable on the pitching mound recently and had decided to change his usual routine to shake things up. He desperately wanted to stop his donut addiction, so he used this opportunity to face his donut demons and come clean with his fellow ballplayers. After that night's game with purge jar in hand, Niekro made an impassioned speech before his shocked teammates. After an hour of crying and sharing their own inner demons, the players hit the post-game buffet with a fuller appreciation of life.

What happened next was a twist of fate that would ultimately cause the (Dusty) Baker's Dozen to be linked to a Baker's Dozen at the donut shop. A notorious practical joker, Braves third baseman Darrell Evans managed to sprinkle some of the contents of Niekro's purge jar onto Phil's plate, thinking it would be hilarious to see Niekro's reaction. However, Niekro was emotionally spent and did not touch any of the food on his plate. Which is where Dusty stepped in. Baker could eat anything at anytime and Niekro's plate, which included a generous portion of regurgitated donut holes, was quickly devoured. As far as Evans was concerned this was even better than if Phil had been able to eat that night. The next day, the diarrhea kicked in and the rest is history, as Evans let everyone know that Baker had eaten Niekro's used donut holes. Naturally the story spread quickly and from then on, at all the local donut shops, whenever someone wanted to gross someone else out, they would hold a jar out and say, "Hey, why don't you make it a Baker's Dozen?" Over time, the story got watered down and became less about the purge and all about getting a 13th donut when only 12 had been paid for...

return to news